Hotels are finding it hard to say if self-service kiosks are helpful or hurting their guest interaction and satisfaction. According to the author, "kiosks can free front desk personnel to spend extra time with guests who prefer or need personal assistance, while enabling business and other travelers to speed through check-in and check-out by serving themselves" (Carlin, 2008). Front desk employees may find this new technology as a threat to their jobs. They can encourage guest use, but guests may want personal interaction. Employees should not rely too heavily on kiosks and should be trained on how to use them. Rosen Hotels & Resorts, Hyatt Hotels & Resorts, and Club Quarters are just a few who have commented on the issue. The consensus seems to be that kiosks are efficient and offers variety to the guest. These hotels also agree that the placement of the kiosk is important for usage. Most are placed by the front desk, or built into the front desk. This would be convenient for an assistant to help if there are problems. Boarding pass printing is also being integrated into the system. The author commented that "future hotel lobbies will incorporate self-service technology into their overall design" (Carlin, 2008). It will function as a hub, similar to a living room in a household, where guests experience can be enhanced.
I think points made by the hotel chains were valid. However, several problems are also present that the author did not bring up in the article. Yes, kiosks are beneficial to the guest by providing them with variety and introducing them to technology in hotels. I used to work at a Hyatt hotel and there are a few things that I doubt managers know about front desk situations. Some guests are very reluctant to use the kiosk and find it hard to navigate. Hyatt hotels require the guest to have the credit card used to book the room to retrieve their reservation. Most actually don't have it and then have to get in line and wait even longer than they should have. If the guest said they requested something but it wasn't given to them, the same thing happens. Plus, when they are at the front of the line, they usually tend to bypass those that are in line making them wait longer. Older guests do not generally want to use the kiosk, so it is very difficult to approach them and ask them if they want to use the kiosk. I was on "kiosk duty" a lot and found that perhaps 1/8 of the time guests used the kiosk and got their room with no problems. Some guests even went up to their room and would come back down because they didn't want or request that room. Interaction with the employee might be easier when it comes down to it.
Carlin, Mary L. February 2008. High Touch vs. Touch Screen. Retrieved March 17, 2008, from HospitalityTechnology, from http://www.htmagazine.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=MultiPublishing&mod=PublishingTitles&mid=3E19674330734FF1BBDA3D67B50C82F1&tier=4&id=1F14B173AACB4D08A3834FA59A12B66D